Skip to main content

Sour Grapes and Reparations

 [Continuing the parables and stories of the teacher and his disciples in Wales]

As the disciples were leaving Cardigan and discussing the Welsh victory there over the invading Normans in 1136, one of them commented on a book he had been reading about the Balkans.  ‘I read the other day that some songs still sung in the Balkans date back to the Battle of Kosovo in 1389 when the Muslim Ottoman Turks invaded the Balkans.  The Christian Orthodox Serbs knew that they were fighting for their lives and homes.  The battle is commemorated annually as a Serbian victory, but the Serbs were weakened after the fighting.  The Ottomans attacked again in 1448 and gained the victory in the Balkans, and they conquered Constantinople in 1453.  To this day, Muslims are the majority in Albania, Kosovo, and Bosnia Herzegovina.  Those songs are part of what has kept tensions alive in the Balkans over the centuries.’

‘The memory of past wrongs can be the engine driving present wrongs,’ commented another disciple.

‘I believe that engine is called “Justice”,’ quipped a third disciple.  ‘The writing of past wrongs in the name of justice all too often is a way to do those living today further wrong.’

‘Some Muslims still commemorate Muhammad’s war against the Jews living in Khaybar way back in 628,’ commented a fourth disciple.  ‘The Jews who did not flee were allowed to stay, as long as they paid half of their harvest to the Muslim victors.  The Khaybar is remembered as a subjugation of the Jews in general, and antisemitic Muslims chant about the Khaybar to this day.’

‘After 7 October, 2023,’ noted the third disciple, ‘that Khaybar chant was heard on social media.’

‘What is the chant?’, asked a fifth disciple.

‘It says, “Khaybar, Khaybar, O Jews! The army of Muhammad will return”.’

‘So,’ noted a sixth disciple, ‘Jews are still threatened with a 1,395 year old memory!  That’s rich!’

‘To be sure, this is a very twisted notion of justice,’ commented the third disciple.

The disciples’ teacher asked, ‘Did not the Apostle say, “we ourselves were once foolish, disobedient, led astray, slaves to various passions and pleasures, passing our days in malice and envy, hated by others and hating one another”?’ [Titus 3.3]

‘And he continues,’ noted a seventh disciple, ‘But when the goodness and loving kindness of God our Savior appeared, he saved us … according to his own mercy, by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit, whom he poured out on us richly through Jesus Christ our Savior….’ [Titus 3.4-6].

‘That is how we overcome past injustices,’ said the teacher.  ‘We must stop stoking the fires of past wrongs others have done to us in the name of “Justice” and of the wrongs we have done to others in the name of “Victory”.  Our Good News is the News of “Goodness and Loving Kindness”, of God’s “Mercy”, of our own “Regeneration and Renewal by the Holy Spirit”, of ‘Salvation in Christ Jesus our Saviour”.  It is the opposite of singing about past battles, past injustices, past hatreds, past victories, and the present subjugation of others.  Did not the Lord teach us to pray, “Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us?”  We have a high calling in this unjust world to be a people who can forgive because we have been forgiven by God’s forgiveness.’

‘But what about reparations?’, asked an eighth disciple.  ‘We read in the news that the Church of England wants to pay countries for its supposed—many dispute this—gains from the slave trade that was stopped by Parliament back in 1808 in English territories.  Christians were deeply involved in calling for the end of the slave trade and slavery itself.’

‘To be sure,’ answered the teacher, ‘forgiveness is not just a matter of “forgive and forget”.  Love does not replace justice, yet we read, “Hatred stirs up strife, but love covers all offenses”.’ [Proverbs 10.12]

A ninth disciple added, ‘And Proverbs also says, “Whoever covers an offense seeks love, but he who repeats a matter separates close friends”.’ [Proverbs 17.9]

‘As Christians,’ stated the teacher, ‘we are told by Peter the Apostle, “Above all, keep loving one another earnestly, since love covers a multitude of sins”.’ [1 Peter 4.8]

‘Yet those verses all point to how we as God’s people respond when we are wronged,’ said the eighth disciple.  ‘What about when we are the ones who have done wrong?’

‘There may be a place to make things right for something done a long time ago,’ commented the teacher.  ‘Truly, however, God alone can sort out the tangle of past injustices, and the longer ago they are, the more tangled they have become.  Shall we go back to the Normans and insist on reparations here in Wales for invading us?  Shall we take some twisted notion of justice into our own hands as the Serbs did against the Bosnian Muslims only a few decades ago by committing genocide?  Does the mixed race ‘black’ person in America demand reparations against himself for enslavement 150 years ago or more?  Should Europeans and Africans demand repayment from Muslim regions that captured slaves for centuries?  And should Europeans demand reparation from the lords who held serfs for centuries as semi-slaves on their lands?  There is coming a Judgement Day, but God is the Judge.  Did not the apostle say, “Beloved, never avenge yourselves, but leave it to the wrath of God, for it is written, “Vengeance is mine, I will repay, says the Lord.” 20 To the contrary, “if your enemy is hungry, feed him; if he is thirsty, give him something to drink; for by so doing you will heap burning coals on his head.” 21 Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good”.’  [Romans 12.19-21]

‘So,’ asked the eighth apostle, ‘Can we never untangle past injustices?’

‘Surely this is something we do try to do,’ replied the teacher.  ‘I am just saying that this is not easy.  And it is a perfect justice even if it is somewhat just, especially when the concerns lay far back in the past.  All too often, those pursuing some form of justice for the past are more interested in virtue signalling by condemning others for the specks in their eyes while ignoring the beams in their own eyes.  Those who are ever on campaigns of social justice about the past are too often trying to prove their own righteousness without any reference to the present.’

‘Can anything else be done?’, asked the eighth disciple.

‘I would suggest that, if obvious wrongs cannot be clearly repaid,’ answered the teacher, ‘we focus more on what good we can do now.  That is, we should repent not so much for the sins of our fathers but for our own sins.  We should forgive one another as we have been forgiven.  And we should do good.’

‘How can we do good?’, asked the eighth disciple.

‘We should do good where a difference can be made for the living more than the dead?’

‘So, are we back to reparations to today’s descendants of slaves, for example?’

‘I personally do not think so,’ answered the teacher, ‘but if you can find someone whose life today is miserable because his great, great, great grandparents were enslaved, make the argument for justice.  Even the urban poor in, say, London, who is the descendant of a slave in, say, Jamaica, is probably poor for other reasons than slavery two hundred years ago.  He very likely has more opportunity than his ancestors who were not enslaved.  The injustices of long ago do not normally explain the challenges people face today.  Indeed, should the smart lawyer in Jamaica whose ancestors worked on the sugar cane fields long ago receive money from a poor Yorkshire churchman trying to feed his family?’

‘Again, how can we do good, then?’

‘There is more than enough good to be done in the present than to try to fix the past,’ answered the teacher.  ‘But to give money to someone with a label like, ‘Victim because an ancestor was wronged’ is not justice and not a matter of doing good.  I would actually say that it is stupid, to be honest.  Shall I give money to such a person if he is a thief, a murderer, a sluggard?  Let us rather look to where good can be done here and now.  If our ancestors wrongly enslaved people, let us work to set people free today.  How about stopping the slave trade where it exists today, with minors in enforced labour, or the sex trade?  If our ancestors wrongly impoverished people, let us work to end poverty through education, starting small businesses, and strengthening families, since much poverty is caused by broken homes.  But to hand out money to individuals, states, foreign governments as though this is going to do good strikes me as more self-serving than helpful.’

‘So,’ said the first disciple, ‘this reminds me of Jesus’ parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus.  The point is that the rich man was punished for ignoring the poor man at his very gate.  Maybe the rich man became rich through injustice, like Zacchaeus the tax collector.  Zacchaeus was able to repay those he had wronged.  He probably had accounts with names and amounts on it so that he could repay them personally.  But the rich man in the parable in Luke 16 was, for whatever reason, rich.  Mind you, he was not a poor man whose ancestor did a wrong.  In any case, his judgement was for not tending to the poor man at his gate.  Who knows, that poor man’s ancestor may have done wrong to someone.  What we have is not some way to interpret the present based on the past but the present situation.  The rich man was punished by God for ignoring the man with great needs who sat right at his gate.’

‘We began by talking about how past memories are kept alive to justify present hatreds,’ said the teacher.  ‘We then discussed whether past wrongs could be righted and, mind you, we left open the possibility that this could sometimes be done.  The problem there is that, the further back one goes, the many wrongs of the past get entangled, and the present descendants of those who were done wrong may be the very people that you would not help by offering them handouts.  Moreover, we noted that such actions are often self-serving or virtue signalling, and they may be more about blaming the dead to misdirect challenges about our own behaviours.  We also noted that, as Christians, we live within a different economy, so to speak, of forgiveness and mercy than the one that demands justice.  And, we concluded with a point from the parable of Jesus of the Rich Man and Lazarus, that we should attend first to the needs at our gate here and now.  If we can satisfy that, perhaps we will have time and opportunity to address the faults of our ancestors in the last century—and there were very many—and the century before that, and so on.  Remember the proverb in Jeremiah, “Each man who eats sour grapes, his teeth shall be set on edge”.’ [Jeremiah 31.30b]

‘What does that mean,’ asked a tenth disciple.

‘It means that “everyone shall die for his own iniquity”,’ answered the teacher.  [Jeremiah 31.30a].  ‘The prophet Ezekiel also discusses this proverb at length in chapter 18.  We should read this during our lunch break at the side of the road.  God says to Ezekiel, ““Now suppose this man fathers a son who sees all the sins that his father has done; he sees, and does not do likewise…. he shall not die for his father’s iniquity; he shall surely live.” [18.14, 17]  He continues, “‘Yet you say, ‘Why should not the son suffer for the iniquity of the father?’ When the son has done what is just and right and has been careful to observe all my statutes, he shall surely live.”’ [18.19]

‘I think,’ said the eleventh disciple, ‘that there is enough evil in our own day to keep us busy doing good to those who are in need here and now, not showing revenge and trying to avenge for the past.’  He quoted the Apostle, “‘Look carefully then how you walk, not as unwise but as wise, making the best use of the time, because the days are evil”.’ [Ephesians 5.15-16]

It was lunch time.  They stopped walking, sat on the side of the road, and opened up the bag of grapes that they had purchased from Sainsbury’s.  They were sour!  The first disciple opened his Bible to Ezekiel 18 and began to read.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Alasdair MacIntyre and Tradition Enquiry

Alasdair MacIntyre's subject is philosophical ethics, and he is best known for his critique of ethics understood as the application of general, universal principles.  He has reintroduced the importance of virtue ethics, along with the role of narrative and community in defining the virtues.  His focus on these things—narrative, community, virtue—combine to form an approach to enquiry which he calls ‘tradition enquiry.’ [1] MacIntyre characterises ethical thinking in the West in our day as ethics that has lost an understanding of the virtues, even if virtues like ‘justice’ are often under discussion.  Greek philosophical ethics, and ethics through to the Enlightenment, focussed ethics on virtue and began with questions of character: 'Who should we be?', rather than questions of action, 'What shall we do?'  Contemporary ethics has focused on the latter question alone, with the magisterial traditions of deontological ('What rules govern our actions?') and tel...

Was Jesus’ Criticism of the Pharisees’ Ethic Its Legalism or Lawlessness?

The popular understanding of the Pharisees is that they were legalists.  This is not, however, Jesus’ criticism of their ethics, even though the charge of Pharisaic legalism comes from a (mis)reading of the Gospels.  The Pharisees are cast in popular imagination as the quintessential example of legalists, overly focussed on rules and promoting works in order to attain righteousness apart from God’s grace.  The latter view, that Judaism overall and the Pharisees in particular advocated works righteousness, has been loudly criticised in light of numerous texts in second temple Judaism, celebrating God’s grace in choosing the Jews, not self-righteous works. [1]   Be that as it may, the Pharisees have remained the foil to Christian ethics precisely over their purported legalism—a focus on unloving, unforgiving rules and regulations that also places norms above, purportedly, higher moral principles.  Jesus’ ethic is contrasted as an ethic of forgiveness, mercy, love...

Early Christian Views on Wealth, Possessions, and Giving

[The following post continues notes and studies on the issue of wealth, poverty, and Christian ethics.  It originally appeared in an online publication: Rollin G. Grams, 'Early Christian Views on Wealth, Possessions, and Giving,'   Explorations (Fall, 2010), an online publication of the Robert C. Cooley Center for the Study of Early Christianity at Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary.  Online:  https://www.scribd.com/document/41882213/The-Cooley-Center-Articles-Early-Christian-Views-on-Wealth ]  For several reasons, study of early Christianity in Protestant circles is on the rise.  Ecumenical dialogue, for instance, requires a return to the common ground of Christian writers prior to the great schisms of the Church throughout history.  Also, an increasing interest in worship and spiritual disciplines has sent some Protestants on pilgrimage to more ancient and liturgical forms of the church.  Recent challenges to long-standing Christian practices...